Sunday 28 December 2014

Last Christmas...

Sunday 28 December

It’s been a couple of days now since I first saw Last Christmas, and I’m still not sure what I think. I really did not like it much on first viewing. I thought the whole dream plot rather obvious and lazy, and the general theme ‘we are all dying and we celebrate Christmas because we think it will be our last’ very bleak. 

On second viewing, I liked it a bit better. Nick Frost’s Santa-with-attitude was excellent, as were the two sarcastic elves, Wolf and Ian. And the juxtaposition of Santa and the Doctor as two impossible beings with implausible means of transport that are bigger on the inside worked well, up to a point. 

But comparing the Doctor in this way with Santa Claus, and emphasising that dreams can be nested within dreams and that we can never know whether we are truly awake, serves to undermine any future stories. How can we be sure that next season isn’t still part of the dream? For that matter, perhaps the last season was part of the dream. I mean, the Moon is a giant egg? Forests that grow overnight to protect the Earth? Missy is surely a creature from the Doctor’s worst nightmare.

 

 

Wednesday 24 December 2014

My Top Ten Christmas Specials: No. 1

And finally... at number one, it is of course The Christmas Invasion.

The first 'real' Christmas Special, in which we meet the Tenth Doctor properly for the first time, and discover what sort of man he is.

It's a brilliant romp, with echoes of Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy (the dressing gown),  Star Trek (Sycorax culture seems rather reminiscent of Klingons) and Star Wars: The Empire Strikes Back (the severed hand).  Plus Jackie almost gets killed by a Christmas tree.

And after all that, the Doctor saves the world with a satsuma, brings down the government and then enjoys Christmas dinner chez Tyler.

What could be more Christmassy than that?

Christmassy factor: 10/10

Victorian/Dickensian Factor: 0/10, but who cares?

Tuesday 23 December 2014

My Top Ten Christmas Specials No. 2

The Unquiet Dead

OK.  Technically, this one isn't actually a Christmas Special, but it should have been.  After all, it's a story with Charles Dickens, at Christmas, with ghosts (as Donna might have put it.) It deserves the number two spot for simply setting the precedent of Christmassy Doctor Who.

It was only the third story to be broadcast after the series returned. Back then, we didn't even have a concept of a Doctor Who Christmas Special, other than William Hartnell taking time out from the Daleks Masterplan to wish everyone a Merry Christmas.

Christmassy Factor: 8/10
Victorian/Dickensian Factor: 10/10


Monday 22 December 2014

My Top Ten Christmas Specials: No 3

No 3: A Christmas Carol

The first Steven Moffat Christmas special, which manages in typical Moffat fashion to be very clever, a bit timey-wimey (how he must regret having written that line!) and very Christmassy.

Like many non-Who Christmas specials, it is basically a rip-off of the plot of the Dickens story, but with the Doctor (and Amy) in the role of the ghosts.  Unlike many non-Who Christmas specials, it is set on a foggy mock-Victorian cyberpunk planet. With fish.  There is an added twist in that reforming the central character is ultimately not sufficient to solve the problem. What the situation really needs is Katherine Jenkins singing to a shark.

Christmassy Factor: 8/10
Victorian/Dickensian Factor: 8/10


Sunday 21 December 2014

My Top Ten Christmas Specials: No. 4

The Doctor, the Widow and the Wardrobe

The Doctor goes to Narnia (well, almost) in this story, which has a real Christmas feel to it. Not only is it set at Christmas, but the Doctor’s special treat for the children is a trip to a snowy planet where real Christmas trees grow, complete with baubles. 

It being Christmas, when things start to go slightly wrong, it is down to mother to sort everything out, and ensure a happy Christmas for everyone. She even makes sure that the Doctor goes off to spend Christmas with his in-laws.

Christmassy factor: 9/10

Dickensian/Victorian Factor 0/10

 

Friday 19 December 2014

My Top Ten Christmas Specials: No 5


Number 5: The Runaway Bride

OK so this is not the most Christmassy of Christmas Specials.  Although it is supposed to take place on Christmas Eve, and the robot Santas make a (slightly implausible) repeat appearance, the bright sunshine doesn’t really convey a festive mood.

But this is the episode where the Tenth Doctor meets Donna, my favourite of his companions.  She takes absolutely no nonsense from him.

And Sarah Parish does a wonderful job of eating the scenery as the Queen of the Racnoss.
Christmassy Factor: 1/10
Victorian/Dickensian Factor: 0/10

Thursday 18 December 2014

My Top Ten Christmas Specials: No 6

Voyage of the Damned

What could be more Christmassy than a disaster movie starring pint-sized pop princess Kylie Minogue?*

Well, quite a few things really, but big budget disaster movies (and Bond films) used to be a centrepiece of Christmas family viewing before we had a Doctor Who Christmas special.  I enjoyed this, but couldn’t help thinking it was a rip-off of my favourite computer game (and the only one I ever managed to win), the brilliant Starship Titanic by former Doctor Who script editor Douglas Adams.  According to The Writer’s Tale, this was an accident, and plans for the episode were well advanced before the similarity was discovered.  The finished episode would have been better if they had included the insane parrot from the game, though.

*I understand that one is legally required always to refer to Ms Minogue as a ‘pint-sized pop princess’

Christmas Factor: 2/10

Victorian/Dickensian Factor: 0/10

Wednesday 17 December 2014

My top ten Christmas Specials: No. 7


Number 7: The Next Doctor
If you are wondering why this Special is number 7, one word: Cybershades. Putting a mask on a hearthrug does not a convincing monster make.
In my 2008 diary I wrote that “The Next Doctor was an enjoyable family film type episode – it was clear very early on that RTD had (as suspected) merely been being evil with the  ‘is it the next incarnation of the Doctor’ hype.”
 
In retrospect, I don’t think the episode is particularly strong once the joke with David Morrissey is over.  The graveyard scene certainly looks good, but it seems to have been included precisely for that reason rather than to further the plot.  And the denouement with the CyberKing and the balloon-TARDIS is incredibly silly. 

Christmas Factor: 3/10
Victorian/Dickensian Factor: 9/10
 
 

Monday 15 December 2014

My Top Ten Christmas Specials: No. 8


The End of Time (Parts 1 and 2)
 
Maybe I’m prejudiced about this story because it was the one in which the Tenth Doctor regenerates, but it doesn’t quite work for me.
 
 Positives:
 
  • Bernard Cribbins
  • The cafĂ© scene
  • Timothy Dalton
Problems:
 
  • The preposterous way in which the Master is brought back to ‘life’ (or almost) at the start
  •  The cliffhanger at the end of part 1
  •  The Doctor’s self-indulgent ‘farewell tour’ at the end. And since he is breaking the rules by doing it anyway, why didn’t he go back to see Reinette as well?
   
What I did enjoy that year was the almost complete takeover of the Christmas TV and radio schedules by David Tennant, who was even on the BBC One station idents and Desert Island Discs. Oh, and I want to be June Whitfield (Minnie).
 

 Christmas Factor: 3/10 - still too bleak
Victorian/Dickensian Factor: 0/10

Saturday 13 December 2014

Top Ten Christmas Specials: Number 9


In at no 9: it’s The Snowmen


The Doctor has parked the TARDIS on a cloud for an extended sulk, whilst Vastra and Jenny from A Good Man Goes to War act as his gatekeepers, assisted by comedy Sontaran Strax, who turns out not to have been permanently killed after all.


Meanwhile, soufflĂ© girl from The Asylum of the Daleks is a barmaid who is moonlighting as a governess. Or possibly the other way round. It’s all very odd.


I found a problem with the tone of this special. It seems to oscillate between Mary Poppins* (the scene where Clara climbs up the staircase to the cloud where the TARDIS is parked) and The Turn of the Screw in the scenes with Clara and the children.


The threat is provided by the eponymous snowmen, but they are being controlled by the real villain of the piece, who is far more abominable than his snowmen. All of which is something of a clue to his identity.


It’s very clever, but this story just didn’t do it for me.

Christmas Factor: 3/10 - still too bleak
Victorian/Dickensian Factor: 7/10 - Victorian London, but points deducted for the Paternoster Gang

*Steven Moffat seems, in the light of more recent episodes, to have something of a Mary Poppins fixation. Is it possible he was traumatised by Julie Andrews as a child?

Sunday 7 December 2014

Vengeance on Varos - ahead of its time?

7 December 2014

Am watching Vengeance on Varos on UK Drama. Somehow I missed seeing this on broadcast.

Watching it in 2014, it's striking how ahead of its time it is.    It starts with two characters talking about what they are watching on TV and then participating in a public vote, as a result of which once of the characters is tortured. Sound at all familiar?

Truly Doctor Who invented Gogglebox and I'm a Celebrity thirty years early.

Meanwhile, the Doctor and Peri are stuck in the TARDIS. Arguing. Again. If I was Peri I would have thrown the TARDIS manual at him by now.

Sil is a really interesting and creepy villain.  It is a shame there wasn't more of a build up to his entrance.

Saturday 6 December 2014

Top Ten Christmas Specials: Number 10

Hard as it is to believe that it's almost ten years since the programme returned to our screens, it's even harder to believe that the Doctor Who Christmas Special has now become as much an integral part of the festivities as over-cooked sprouts.

In order to celebrate, I'm going to do my own personal top ten of the Christmas specials. 

So, in reverse order, here we go with number 10:

Time of the Doctor (2013)

I'm sorry, but I don't think this one worked. My diary for Christmas Day 2013 says "Time of the Doctor was depressing and longwinded. Didn’t enjoy it at all. Even after having watched it again."

Particular problems were:

  • Clara's family: We had never really met Clara's own family before. Now they were parachuted in for Christmas.  To the Powell Estate (or somewhere suspiciously like it).

  • The nudity: Don't get me wrong.  I don't mind the Doctor being naked, but there is a time and a place for it. (Generally in the TARDIS, when the Tenth Doctor is having a metacrisis). But in this story it just seemed like an excuse for cheap jokes.

  • The turkey: I thought the turkey that they were cooking in the time rotor was going to turn out to save Christmas (the place), or at least Christmas (the celebration), in a sort of Three Doctors  recorder kind of way, but it wasn't.

  • A town called Christmas: a town. Called Christmas. On Trenzalore. I ask you!

  • Handles: the Doctor has a pet Cyberman head?

  • The Doctor ageing to death naturally: a new idea, but a very depressing one for Christmas. 
Overall the programme seemed too long, too downbeat, and rather hampered by the number of hanging plot threads from previous episodes that needed to be tied up.  I'm still not entirely clear why the Silence were trying to blow up the TARDIS, who Prisoner Zero was or where the Leadworth ducks went.

Christmas Factor: 2/10 - too bleak
Dickensian/Victorian Factor: 5/10 - spurious Victorian atmosphere in implausibly-named town on a distant planet.
So that was number 10. What will be number 9?

Sunday 30 November 2014

Farewell Adric

Sunday 29 November 2014

Today's offering from UK Drama is Earthshock, which I believe may hold the record as the last Doctor Who story with a spoiler-free ending.  Well, apart possibly from the surprise appearance of Rose at the end of Partners in Crime.

At the time, I was quite upset about Adric's demise, as I had rather a soft spot for him.   

I can't remember having watched this since it was first broadcast, and it seems likely that I haven't, as we don't appear to have a copy.  (The husband has just been doing a stocktake of our VHS and DVD Doctor Who library, and can't find it - yes, we really know how to enjoy ourselves on a Sunday!)

Later:

Adric is having a massive teenage strop.  I don't remember that at all.  Though unlike most teenagers, he wants to go home, rather than go out.

I do remember the Cybermen from this episode, though.  I still think the design is a bit too elaborate, and the voices are rather too fruity and not metallic enough. Plus they say 'excellent' rather too much. Not at all scary.

Beryl Reid has to be the least believable space freighter captain ever.

Sunday 23 November 2014

Happy Birthday, Doctor!

Today is the 51st anniversary of Doctor Who.

A year ago, I was at the ExCel Centre for the Fiftieth celebrations.

Not surprisingly, for an event with several thousand attendees, a certain amount of queuing was involved. Initially, we joined the other ‘Weeping Angels’ in a holding area. After a while we were allowed to proceed to the registration hall. En route we passed a number of cafĂ©s, but decided not to stop for breakfast until after we had registered. This proved to be something of a mistake, as although registration was swift – our tickets were scanned and we were handed our badges and lanyards, we were then held in a huge queue in the hall for half an hour.

 Once we got moving again we grabbed a drink and a pastry and made our way to the ‘Classic Lounge’ for a panel with Frazer Hines and Debbie Watling. The Classic Lounge area was at some distance from the main hall and exhibition area and felt like an old-style convention. Frazer and Debbie were good value, as ever. The recent recovery of tapes of Enemy of the World and The Web of Fear provided a talking point. Debbie Watling revealed her nervousness about the helicopter scene in Enemy of the World. She got Frazer to promise he would let her sit in the middle, but on the take he outran her, leaving her with the precarious outside seat. It was so cold on the location for the supposed Australian beach that Frazer’s knees turned blue. His then girlfriend, Susan George, who was visiting, had to massage them back to life (or at least that was his excuse).

Our next event was a Panel in the main auditorium. After queuing for a while, we finally took our seats for what proved to be a Panel with the surviving Doctors from the ‘classic’ series: Messrs Baker, Tom; Davison; Baker, Colin; McCoy and McGann. This Panel was hosted by Nicholas (‘Get lost Nick, you Bald Git’ – you see, I can’t stop myself) Briggs. There was also a sign language interpreter on stage, and the Doctors, having discovered the previous day that the sign for ‘Nicola Bryant’s cleavage’ (Peter Davison’s last sight before regeneration) was rather entertaining, took mischievous delight in mentioning it as often as possible. Unfortunately, this Panel, which had started late, ended at the scheduled time, leaving us feeling slightly short changed.


We remained in our seats for another Panel, this time with the current team: producer Marcus Wilson, Steven Moffat, Jenna Coleman and Matt Smith. Steven Moffat once again exhibited his talent for giving nothing whatsoever away, though he did joke about Matt leaving ‘to pursue a career in musical theatre.’ (Matt appeared in ‘American Psycho’ the musical.)

After a quick lunch (the organisers had made sure there were plenty of catering outlets, with one hall devoted to food stalls supplementing the ExCeL’s in-house facilities), we ventured into the main exhibition area. (We had avoided the area earlier, as Graham Norton was doing a live broadcast of his Saturday morning Radio Two Show. That man’s ability to gatecrash Doctor Who is remarkable.) Once inside the exhibition hall we found a costume and prop exhibition, which included both classic and new series, as well as The Sarah Jane Adventures and An Adventure in Time and Space. There was also an opportunity to play with a ring modulator in order to talk like a Dalek. My companion took the opportunity to recite a risquĂ© limerick. There were also demonstrations of make-up and workshops on how to walk like a monster, as well as some smaller panels. I caught the end of one panel with Janet Fielding and Sarah Sutton. The merchandising area offered anything you could possibly want, from books, audios and DVDs, to expensive limited edition sonic screwdriver sets and replica Doctor coats. 

Our next event was another Classic Lounge panel, this time with William Russell and Carole Ann Ford. This was interesting, but slightly marred by a problem with William Russell’s microphone. After that, there was a special effects demonstration with Danny Hargreaves in the main auditorium. However, as we had already seen a similar demonstration in Cardiff, I was persuaded instead to go to a screening of the final episode of The Three Doctors, with live commentary by Terrance Dicks. This was very entertaining, although the reminiscences in the commentary bore little relation to what was actually on the screen. After a final look round the exhibition, we left the event. It had been fascinating, though not quite as enjoyable as the previous year’s Cardiff event, which had had the added attraction of taking place in a Doctor Who location – the Millennium Centre - and had also provided the once in a lifetime opportunity to visit the TARDIS set at the Upper Boat studio and play with the console.

In the evening we returned to the ExCeL Centre for a live screening of Day of the Doctor. This naturally enough involved another long queue. In front of us in the queue was someone dressed as a Time Lord, and I was a bit worried that we would end up sitting behind him, but in the event we had a good view. The screening was introduced by a short panel, which included Dalek operators Barnaby Edwards and Nicholas Pegg. Most of the other ‘celebrity’ guests had decamped to the BFI -we had earlier passed Colin Baker on an escalator as he was leaving the event to go to the screening there. Nevertheless, The Day of the Doctor was the highlight of the day – a truly wonderful episode.

Queuing for the 'Day of the Doctor' screening













See you at the Sixtieth Anniversary!




Saturday 22 November 2014

Profile of a Who fan... or perhaps not

Saturday 22 November

Since everyone else seems to have been playing with the YouGov Profiler site, I thought I would challenge it to see how typical I am of a Doctor Who viewer.  I duly entered 'Doctor Who' in the criteria.

Here is what it came up with:

Demographics

Gender: Male  (OK, failed at the first hurdle!)

Aged: 40-59 (That's more like it!)

Social Grade: C2DE (Not commenting on this one except to say that I neither live in Islington nor own a white van, so make of that what you will).

Top Regions: South Coast, Yorkshire, North East. (No, no and no.)

Lifestyle

Favourite dishes: hot dogs, chicken soup, Madeira cake, chocolate muffin, banana milkshake and various things I haven't even heard of. (Not exactly healthy eating, are they? I'm not sure exactly what my 'favourite dishes' are, but these are certainly not they.)

Hobbies and Activities: writing, using the internet and going to museums and galleries (pretty well spot on there.)

Favourite sports: Formula One and Athletics (You have got to be joking! I hate all sport).

General Interests: Science, video games and movies. (Try history, crime fiction and gardening!)

Niche Interests: Science and Technology, newspaper cartoons, sustainability charities, culture and the arts, arts and culture charities. (So what exactly is the difference between a 'general' interest and a 'niche' interest? 2/5, could do better!)

Most likely pet: Cat.  (No way!  Sorry.  Will have to leave the internet now, I suppose.)

Brands

Shops at: Co-op. (Yes, but only because the three nearest shops to my house have all been taken over by Co-op.  Would be perfectly happy to shop at Tesco, Morrisons or Waitrose if they were more convenient.  But not Sainsbury. I have an irrational dislike of Sainsbury.)

Most likely car: Daihatsu.  (That's a car?  Sounds more like a martial art to me.)

Clothing brands: Air Walk, Reebok and Joe Browns.  (Well, I think I've heard of Reebok, but I don't even own any trainers/sneakers.)

Entertainment

Favourite Movies: Doctor Who: Day of the Doctor (that might have been shown in cinemas, but it's NOT a movie, great though it is.); Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan; Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home; Galaxy Quest. (I think I see a theme emerging here.  But whilst I quite like these films, my favourite is Charade, followed by the original version of The Italian Job.

Favourite TV Shows: Torchwood, Merlin, Red Dwarf, The X-Files, Life on Mars.  (Haven't they heard of Broadchurch?)

Favourite music artists: Wizzard (I think they are having a laugh, don't you?), The Human League, Slade, Madness and A-Ha. (Billy Joel, The Divine Comedy, the Duckworth Lewis Method and Meatloaf.  I never said I had taste, did I?).

Favourite celebrities: Davit Tennant, John Barrowman, Matt Smith, Russell T Davies and Steven Moffat. (Amazing! I wonder how on earth they came up with that selection? 2/5, actually. Serves them right for trying to be clever.)

Media

Newspaper read: The Guardian. (No, too depressing.  The Times has funnier columnists).

Magazines read recently: Empire.  (No, Doctor Who Magazine, Good Housekeeping and The Garden. Pick the bones out of that, YouGov!)

TV Shows watched recently: Doctor Who  (who would have thought it?), Sherlock, The Big Bang Theory,  Marvel's Agents of SHIELD.  (Bang to rights on the first two, but I've never seen the others as I have been too busy watching Masterchef.)

Verdict

Apart from the really obvious connections, they haven't got much right at all.  But it is good fun to play with.






Thursday 20 November 2014

Revisiting some old faces

The UK Drama Channel (Freeview channel 20) is currently showing some classic Doctor Who stories, one for each of the pre-2005 Doctors on Sunday afternoons at 4.00 p.m.  Just the thing watch whilst doing the ironing!

They started with The Aztecs, which is watchable enough, but not one of the best surviving Hartnell stories, in my opinion. This was followed by Tomb of the Cybermen, which is one of the classic Troughton stories, and one which actually manages to make the Cybermen creepy and scary.  (In general I think Doomsday was quite right and that Daleks beat Cybermen any day.)

Last week it was the turn of Pertwee, and Spearhead from Space.  I enjoyed this so much that I followed it by watching Rose on DVD in order to compare the effects of two very different new Doctor stories/series reboots starring Autons.  In both cases the shop dummies work much better than the Nestene Consciousness, which is slightly disappointing in both its felt tentacle and orange CGI guises.

This Sunday the channel will be celebrating the Doctor's 51st birthday with one of my all-time favourite stories, and one which genuinely terrified me as a child, The Pyramids of Mars. Between that and Sexton Blake and the Demon God (broadcast in the Sunday teatime slot in1978), I was definitely traumatised by all things Eygptian.

 It won't stop me from watching on Sunday though, even if I'm hiding behind the ironing board.




Saturday 15 November 2014

Och Aye the Doctor!


14 November 2014

Tonight I went to a lecture for alumni of my former university history department. With the aim of giving the event some topical relevance, it was on ‘Making the Union Work, 1707-2014’.  Although wine and canapes were provided, we could tell that it was a serious academic event.  There was even a handout, giving an ‘illustrative chronology’, starting with the union of the crowns in 1603 and proceeding via various political and cultural landmarks such as the abolition of the Scottish privy council in 1708 and the publication of the first of Sir Walter Scott’s Waverley novels in 1814.  The distinguished professor explained that this was intended to give us something to look at if our attention wandered during his lecture.

Somewhere around Adam Smith, I found my attention wandering and  turned over the sheet to read ‘2013 – Peter Capaldi as Dr Who; the third Scot to play the role, out of 12 – is that right Helen and Neil? Towards the end of the talk, the DP, making a point about Scotland’s place in ‘British’ culture duly referred to Peter Capaldi as the third Scottish Doctor out of 12, at least according to Wikipedia, and turned to us for corroboration. My other half agreed that this was correct (it wasn’t the time or place to get into Steven Moffat’s messing with the incarnations) and mentioned the ‘I’m Scottish, I can complain about things’ line from Peter Capaldi’s  first episode. I was far too shocked at the Astor Professor of British History using  Wikipedia  to be able to comment.*

But it got me thinking about Scottishness in Doctor Who. 

I am too young to have seen The Highlanders (though we do have the Target novelisation), but it seems to be based on the romanticised view of Scottish history purveyed by Sir Walter Scott.  (Distinguished Professor is not a fan of the Waverley novels.) It also introduced Jamie McCrimmon, the kilt-wearing companion.

The romanticised view of Scotland was still somewhat in evidence with gratuitous tartan-wearing in Terror of the Zygons in which the Brigadier suddenly seems to remember that his name is Lethbridge-Stewart, and even Nessie makes an appearance (though it turns out she’s an alien creature).

Tooth and Claw is rather less self-consciously Scottish.  Although it gives David Tennant a brief opportunity to use his own accent instead of the Tenth Doctor’s terrible estuary accent, there is rather less of the tartan, bagpipes and Bonnie Prince Charlie in evidence.  They have Kung-fu monks instead for reasons which still escape me.

Steven Moffat’s Scottish stereotyping has been of a rather more modern kind.  As a Scot himself, he can get away with writing  lines such as ‘you’re Scottish – fry something!’
*I should point out that Professor in question does not watch Doctor Who, but was the Head of Department whose meeting was once crashed by Derek the Departmental Dalek. It was clearly a traumatic experience.

Sunday 9 November 2014

Liar, Liar! Death in Heaven reappraised (spoilers)

Sunday 9 November

Now I have seen Death in Heaven a second time, and I'm slightly more positive about it.

There are some weak points. The Cyber-pollen made a bit more sense second time around, but I still don't understand how Missy's magic bracelet/vortex manipulator/teleport could bring the boy Danny killed in Afghanistan back to life in Clara's flat. 'Time Lord technology' really isn't a good enough explanation.

Whilst Danny and the Doctor have never really got on, I found the way Cyber-Danny seemed to equate the Doctor with the officer class he despised a bit forced. It seemed as though Steven Moffat was trying to shoehorn in a reference to the old 'lions led by donkeys' view of the First World War.

On first viewing, I didn't register the significance of lying. We all know that rule number one is 'the Doctor lies' and that Clara has been lying to Danny for much of this season, but this really came to a head in Death in Heaven.

Clara lies to the Cybermen.

Seb lies to the people uploaded to the Nethersphere.

Missy lies to everyone, but particularly to the Doctor.

In the end, the Doctor and Clara lie to each other.

I don't know quite why Santa Claus has turned up, but with all that lying going on, I doubt that it's to fill the Doctor's Christmas stocking.



Death in Heaven: Initial thoughts (spoilers)

So what did I do?  I turned off everything connected to the internet and sat down to enjoy Partners in Crime and Fires of Pompeii, of course, and to be honest, I enjoyed them both rather more than some of the more recent series.

When the husband finally reappeared, he announced that we would watch Death in Heaven  straight away. This may have affected my appreciation of it, as I was half asleep by then.  I'll need to watch again to confirm my impression of it.

First impressions though:

As with many season finales, there was too much going on. The action was rushed in places, whilst there were also pauses for emotional scenes that didn't always work, and the plot was somewhat hard to follow in places.

Positives:

  • I like the Missy incarnation of the Master. She's totally bonkers, but also recognisably the same person as the John Simm version.

  • Osgood was excellent, and her death was shocking, although it was clear that the writing was on the wall when the Doctor appeared to offer her a trip in the TARDIS. 

  • The Cyber-Danny also worked well, and was a logical continuation from Doomsday where the converted Yvonne still performs her 'duty to Queen and Country.'

  • The pre-credit wind-up with Clara pretending to be the Doctor (which carried over into the opening credits).  It was obviously done so that they could have a clip in the trailer of her saying that Clara Oswald never existed, so full marks for an excellent fan teaser.

Negatives:


  •  Earth Force One and the Doctor-President. (I never cared much for the Valiant, either). The whole idea of a planet-wide response to anything is implausible, and UNIT really ought to know by now that the Doctor doesn't do positions of responsibility.

  • I didn't really get the point of the cyber-pollen turning the dead into Cybermen.  The original point of Cybermen was that they had replaced parts of their bodies with cybernetics, so why would they need real skeletons, when they could easily use artificial ones? And why harvest human minds to populate the bodies, when they have to delete the emotions that make them human?

  • The magic bracelet or whatever it was that allowed one person to 'cross back over' with a living body didn't make sense.  Yes, it worked as an emotional climax to the episode, but how was it possible, given that the bodies had been cyber-converted?

  • The Cyber-Brig: I suppose it was a nice idea, but I find it somehow disrespectful.  And if any of UNIT had to survive, I would have preferred Osgood to the annoying Kate.

In retrospect, I suspect that the theme was designed to fit in with the broadcast on the weekend of Remembrance Day, but at the moment, I think Family of Blood addressed this far more effectively.


Friday 7 November 2014

So what should 'A'do?

I have a problem. The husband,  the one who is responsible for my Doctor Who obsession, has managed to arrange a night out tomorrow.

Without me. Which is fine, obviously, but as tomorrow night is the season finale, Death in Heaven, I'm left with a problem.

Should I:

a) Nobly stay away from the TV and the Internet until Sunday when we can watch it together;

b) Watch it anyway, but pretend I haven't?

c) Watch it anyway and tease him with spoilers?

I haven't decided yet, so watch this space.

***
Update:

Husband is confident that I will go for option A.

Meanwhile, I have thought of option D: watch something else but tweet random comments about Doctor Who  and Peter Capaldi to wind him up.  The Fires of Pompeii  should do nicely.

***

Further update:

He's gone. It's making my mind up time.

Saturday 1 November 2014

Dark Water -first thoughts

So now we know who Missy is. It was obvious, in retrospect. 

That was definitely one the best episodes of this (fairly mediocre) season. I loved the visual references to Tomb of the Cybermen and The Invasion. I was less sure about the dream sequence, firstly because they are always a cop-out, but also because it just felt wrong that Clara would feel she had to threaten the Doctor to get her way.

What does Steven Moffat have against the boyfriends of the Doctor's companions? He does like killing them off.  Repeatedly, in the case of poor old Rory. They are fast becoming the equivalent of Star Trek's ensign in the red shirt. Time will tell whether Danny's demise is permanent.

I can't help feeling the BBC will get complaints from a) Apple and b) Crematorium owners.

Roll on next week!




Who is Missy?

1 November 2014

Today is the start of the season finale, and we will (I hope) find out the identity of the mysterious Missy.

There are many theories about this character:
  • She is Susan.  Susan is the Doctor's granddaughter (or at least used to call him 'Grandfather') whereas Missy refers to him as 'my boyfriend'. So this can't be right as it's just too creepy and weird.

  • She is a regenerated Rani.  Unlikely. The Doctor and the Master are supposedly the only Time Lords who survived the Time War. Unless the Nethersphere is in the same pocket universe that Gallifrey was saved to in Day of the Doctor.

  • She is a regenerated Master.  Slightly more plausible.  We don't know exactly what happened to the Master at the end The End of Time - he disappeared into a white expanse.  This could have been some sort of alternative universe where he regenerated into Michelle Gomez. And 'Missy' could be short for 'Mistress', as in female version of 'Master'. Also the slightly bonkers aspect does seem a bit reminiscent of John Simm's Master, though perhaps too much so. 

  • She is River Song. The arch way of referring to the Doctor would be more in keeping, but given that we saw her regenerate into her Alex Kingston appearance and then use up her remaining regenerations, and that this incarnation later (or earlier)  'died' in the Library, this seems unlikely.  Unless the Nethersphere is actually inside CAL, where River's pattern was saved.. Hang on, that needs thinking through...

  • She is an entirely new character we have not encountered before. 
Given Steven Moffat's record, my theory is that he will make us wait another couple of seasons to find out.

Meanwhile, who exactly is Clara?

Sunday 26 October 2014

Merchandise, Merchandise

One of the advantages/perils of being known to be a Doctor Who fan, is that people give you merchandise as gifts.

In the dark days of the mid-nineties, my leaving present from a job included David Banks' Cybermen book and a poster of the Daleks crossing Westminster Bridge. The poster duly graced my office wall in my next two jobs.

Then there was the inflatable Dalek that a couple of History professors left outside my office.

But books and Daleks, whether in photo or blow-up formats are fine.  Jigsaws are another matter entirely.

Don't get me wrong, Vincent and the Doctor and The Pandorica Opens are great stories, but the person who thought that the Van Gogh picture of the exploding TARDIS would make an excellent jigsaw should have both his ears cut off.  

The colleague who gave me this abomination wanted photographic proof of the completed article, all 2,000 pieces of it.  All the pieces were either dark blue, or multi-coloured swirls that could have gone anywhere. The only place to do it was my dining table, so I had an added incentive to complete it, or never have Sunday lunch again.

It took six weeks....

Thursday 23 October 2014

I set foot in the TARDIS

2012
 


When we heard that the BBC were arranging an official convention – in Cardiff- we knew we had to go. Remembering that Panopticon 2003 had been  bit of a let-down,  I deliberately set my expectations low and booked into the posh hotel. My idea was that we would have a pleasant weekend away even if the convention was a disappointment.  I need not have worried.

Breakfast on the morning of Saturday 24 March was enlivened by the sight of Nick ‘Voice of the Daleks’ Briggs in a claret velvet jacket, selecting a banana from the buffet.  Bananas are good, as Steven Moffat’s scripts are wont to say. I first encountered Mr Briggs at Panopticon 1993, when as host, he encouraged the audience to shout ‘Get lost Nick, you bald git!’ at him. The residual Pavlovian training was very strong, but I just about managed not to shout it out at him in the hotel dining room.


The Convention timetable had two tracks: Ood and Silurian, with the same events running at different times for each group. As Silurians, we had a slightly later start than the Ood.  We walked to the Millennium Centre and joined the massive queue outside the ‘Silurian’ entrance.  Convention crew in yellow t-shirts patrolled the queue and scanned our tickets.  We couldn’t help feeling that they should have had Judoon to do this, but there was no sign (yet) of the Rhino police, although there was a Silurian wandering around.  It was a glorious day, and Murray Gold’s soundtrack was playing, so the time passed quite pleasantly. Before long we were inside, collecting our goody bags. As well as our passes, the bags contained the programme, a DVD of Series 5 volume 1, and souvenir postcards. We were also given a wrist band for the 9.30 a.m. Special Effects Studio session, so we joined another queue for entry to this. But just as we reached the front of the queue, they decided the room was at capacity, so we were turned away and given tickets for the 2.00 p.m. show instead.  In fairness, this was the only organisational hiccup we experienced. 

Foiled, we returned to the foyer to watch the prosthetics demonstration by Millennium FX instead. I then made the serendipitous discovery that it was possible to buy a coffee at the foyer cafĂ© and drink it at a table with excellent view of the demonstration.  This is a luxury I had not experienced at any previous Doctor Who convention, catering not normally being a strong point of such events. This particular  demonstration focused on the Scarecrows from Human Nature/Family of Blood. Monster regular Ruari Mears demonstrated the Scarecrow walk both in and out of costume. It looked incredibly camp without Scarecrow mask on. A member of the audience was also given the opportunity of trying on a Scarecrow mask and walking with the very restricted vision that entailed. Ruari also told some anecdotes about what happens when a Cyberman sneezes inside his helmet (yuk – almost put me off my coffee!), and how as an Ood in The Satan Pit he missed the turning in the ducting and fell right out of the rig.

After the demo it was time to joint another almighty queue to get to Donald Gordon Theatre for our first panel of the day: Meet the Stars.  Signs on the way in forbade the use of cameras, but the stewards said that it was OK to take pictures without flash. I dutifully turned off my flash, though I noticed quite a view flashes going off in the auditorium without anyone being exterminated or asked to leave.  The interviewer was Jason Mohammed (a news and sport presenter for BBC Wales, who played TV News Anchor in the 2007 Christmas Special.) The panel guests were Arthur Darvill, Karen Gillan, Matt Smith, Steven Moffat and Caroline Skinner (the new-ish executive producer). I don’t know whether the current TARDIS crew end Executive Producers have ever all appeared on stage at a UK convention before – certainly not for a very long time. The Panel  highlights were probably the questions from the audience. One little girl’s question to Matt Smith was ‘Would you like to come to the cinema with me tonight?’ He gracefully declined, explaining that his family were visiting that weekend. Another fan, seated near the front, somehow managed to get Matt to offer him a jammy dodger from the plate on stage, and then went up on stage for a hug. At one point Matt suffered a slip of the tongue and started talking about ‘Doctor Ho’ – which would be a different show entirely. ( I expect to see a video of this on YouTube sometime soon!) Someone asked Arthur Darvill what it was like being Rory in the street, and he replied, reasonably enough, that he was Arthur when he was out in the street.  One member of the audience asked Matt how the Doctor made a new sonic screwdriver and Matt came out with a brilliant explanation in fluent technobabble, which shows that he probably doesn’t need the scriptwriters at all. Steven Moffat was visibly impressed. A Silurian and a Judoon joined the party on stage at one point, causing Karen to jump.


We stayed in our seats for the next panel, which was ‘Creators and Directors’ hosted by Gary Russell.  This was based on one particular episode, The Girl Who Waited.  The guests included the writer Tom MacRae, producer Marcus Wilson and the designer of the Handbots. They were later joined on stage by a Handbot. This Panel revealed some of the trickery behind the filming. You may recall a scene in which Rory walked through a door which closed behind him, then he pressed another button and opened it again to reveal a different room.  This was achieved by the low-tech method of lots of people just out of shot who ran over as soon as the doors closed and moved things around, rather like the old lift joke from Candid Camera and Beadle’s About.

During the lunch break we went out to get some fresh air, leaving the Millennium Centre for the delights of a sandwich at RTD’s favourite coffee bar, Coffee Mania.

On our return we finally got to see the Special Effects demo, hosted by Danny Hargreaves, the undoubted star of Doctor Who Confidential . He demonstrated the ‘air woofer’ which can fire all sorts of fake debris.  A volunteer from the audience was entrusted with the job of firing a big gun at a Cyberman, whilst another young volunteer pressed the red button that set off charges on the Cybersuit just at the same time as the shot was fired, to make it look as if the Cyberman had been hit. We also had a demonstration of fake snow falling and X-Factor style smoke. Danny demonstrated his scary- looking paintball gun that generated sparks on a wall. He explained that this had been designed to look like a submachine gun because it was ‘cool’. He mentioned that one of his favourite jobs had been blowing up the military base on Torchwood: Miracle Day. This had been shot on a real military base, and men with guns had given him strict instructions not to blow anything up. As he explained, he didn’t actually blow it up, he just set it on fire slightly and burnt it a little bit. After the demo finished, the Cyberman posed for photos with fans, while Danny was happy to provide individual career advice on how to get to blow things up for a living.

We then had some time to visit the costume exhibition. This was familiar from the Doctor Who Experience at Earl’s Court, although with some more recent additions, including the King and Queen from the 2011 Christmas Special. One of the peg dolls from Night Terrors was actually an actor in costume, who moved from time to time to freak visitors out. 

We returned to the main auditorium for the final panel: Doctor Who Uncut – hosted by Dalek  operator Barnaby Edwards. The guests included Steven Moffat, Caroline Skinner, Production Designer Michael Pickwoad, Director of Photography Stephan Pehrsson, Director Julian Simpson and Casting Director Andy Pryor. The highlight of this session was the preview screening of the Series 7 (Fnarg+2?) trailer. Steven Moffat spent most of the Q & A trying not to give away any secrets in response to some carefully-loaded questions from the fans.  One question he was able to answer was ‘will there be a Sherlock / Doctor Who crossover?’ The answer was no, because a)they would end up punching each other; and b) Sherlock would no longer work if the rational certainties of Sherlock’s world were undermined by the Whoniverse.
That ended the formal business of the convention, and we went off to dinner in Bellini’s (Margaret Slitheen’s favourite restaurant), escaping before the hen parties got too rowdy.

The following morning we saw Ian McNeice (Winston Churchill) and Mark Sheppard (Canton Delaware III) at breakfast. Ian McNeice appeared to have come dressed as his character from Doc Martin.  As our set tour wasn’t until late afternoon, we walked into the city centre to avoid getting caught up with the Sport Relief Mile, which was taking place just outside the Millennium Centre. On returning in the afternoon, we were in time to see a Black Dalek that had completed the event proudly wearing his Sport Relief medal and shooting at children in the crowd (with a water pistol in his sink plunger).

The final event of our Who weekend was the coach trip to see the TARDIS set at the studios at Upper Boat. We were given either red or green wristbands, as the tour would be in two groups. We arrived slightly early, before the previous coachload were quite ready to leave, but we were allowed to get off the coach, with the strict injunction not to ‘go wandering off’. Now, where have I heard that before? As we had red wristbands, we were directed first to the ‘Blue Box CafĂ©’.  This could be a reference to the TARDIS, but it is genuinely a blue box, well, a Portacabin. Inside, they sold Starbucks coffee and had a screen showing A Good Man Goes to War.  After about half an hour, it was our turn on the set.  What can I say? We were on the real TARDIS set, and they let us touch it, and everything!

I had been expecting the convention to be very strict and formal, rather like the last Panopticon I attended (2003), with jobsworth stewards and injunctions not to touch the replica TARDIS console. In fact, the stewards were very friendly and helpful, and there was a very relaxed atmosphere.  We were allowed to play with the real TARDIS set, and no one minded when bits fell off (a common occurrence during filming). The queues were long, but moved swiftly, and even the sun shone for the whole weekend.  The only quibble I would have is that the guest actors were only available for photo/autograph opportunities, which I did not bother with, and did not participate in the Panel sessions.

I hope that similar events are organised for the 50th anniversary next year. Perhaps with some previous Doctors in attendance as well…

All Aboard the Bandwagon!




For some time I have noticed the number of times that references to Doctor Who appear in quite unexpected books. It can be quite a good game to play if you happen to be in a bookshop with some time to kill.

I first noticed this phenomenon with The Kenneth Williams Diaries (ed. Hunter Davies, Harper Collins, 1993).  On Saturday 29 November 1975, Willams observed that ‘Dr Who gets more and more silly.’ Episode 2 of The Android Invasion was clearly not his cup of tea, but the idea that Kenneth Williams was a regular viewer of the programme takes a little getting used to. It is a huge shame he never appeared in it – he couldn’t have been any worse than Ken Dodd.

I have subsequently found references to Doctor Who in a number of showbusiness autobiographies by people who never appeared in the show. Aled Jones (Virgin Books, 2005), stakes a claim for his interest in the programme with a wealth of circumstantial detail. ‘The other programme that I never missed was Doctor Who. True to tradition, the moment the music started, I would dive behind our leather sofa, from where I would watch the whole episode. I was particularly frightened of the Daleks and would hide every time they came on screen. But, despite my fear, I still desperately wanted to watch it each week. One day when she was cleaning, Mam discovered that I had been nervously gnawing away at the back of the sofa and that her pride and joy now had teeth marks all the way along the top from one end to the other.’

Nigel Havers’s autobiography Playing with Fire (Headline Review, 2006) contains a photo which purports to show Nigel and his father watching the very first episode of Doctor Who. Given that in a Doctor Who Magazine interview Mr Havers claimed only ever to have watched the first episode prior to performing in one of the Big Finish audio adventures for BBC7 it shows rare foresight to have had a photograph taken of the occasion.  Cynics might however point out that the television screen is not visible in the photo.

References to Doctor Who are not confined to autobiographies, however. I recently read First Among Sequels by Jasper Fforde (Hodder, 2007), set in an alternative reality Swindon, which contains a scene in which not only does the heroine’s brother come to collect a video of Remembrance of the Daleks, but there is a discussion about who was the best Doctor: ‘“It was Tom Baker,” said Joffy, ending the embarrassed silence. Miles made a noise that sounded like “conventionalist”, and Landen went off to fetch the tape.’

Now that Doctor Who is popular again (for the moment) these references are likely to increase.

All aboard the bandwagon!


Featured post

Extenuating Circumstances

A while ago I pointed out that my university colleague and I had concerns about the personal tutoring arrangement between Bill and the Docto...