Monday 17 July 2017
So the new Doctor is going to be Jodie Whittaker, with whom the incoming showrunner has worked extensively on Broadchurch. She is white, thirty-something and not ginger. I may have been just a tiny bit wrong about the gender*, but apart from being female the casting seems completely in the usual pattern and therefore unremarkable.
So, leaving aside the competing and equally blinkered views of 'finally, a woman!' and 'it's ruined and I'm never watching again', what are we to make of the casting?
Firstly, Jodie Whittaker is an excellent actor. Her role in Broadchurch mainly involved a lot of emotional angst as a grieving mother, so it will be interesting to see how she deals with the more quirky aspects of the Doctor's personality.
Secondly, the publicity photos remind me quite a lot of Romana 2. (I mentioned this to my German colleague at work, but he had never heard of the Time Lady in question. I am disappointed in him.) Will the Thirteenth Doctor actually turn out to be rather like Romana? And if so, can we have a K9 substitute? An electric parrot or a talking cabbage would be good.
Thirdly, will we now get a new male companion? The last two series have ended with a female companion of the Doctor flying off to explore the universe along with another female character (Clara and Ashildr/Me last year and Bill and Heather this year), so two women flying around the space time continuum has been done. Perhaps Chris Chibnall could find a way of reintroducing Rory? It is important to have some sort of gender balance in the TARDIS. If all else fails, Captain Jack will do nicely.
Anyway, I'm looking forward to Christmas.
*I'm open-minded about this. I don't see any need for the Doctor to change gender, but don't mind as long as it has been done in order to take the series in new directions and explore new stories, rather than as a gimmick or to appease the feminist lobby.
Showing posts with label Bill. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bill. Show all posts
Monday, 17 July 2017
Sunday, 2 July 2017
Little House on the Solar Farm
Saturday 1 July 2017
After a very nice celebration lunch we were home in plenty of time for the Doctor Who finale, hoping that it wouldn't turn out to be a disappointment that spoiled the day. I've found that with two-parters the set-up is often better than the conclusion. So was that the case here?
There was a lot to enjoy, particularly the situation with Missy and the Master. Missy is in two minds about whose side she is on "fortunately one of them is unconscious."
But the scene soon shifts from the creepy hospital to floor 507, where settlers are protecting the children in a homestead straight out of The Waltons. Bill is having identity issues (though I wonder why she has more problems with the 'Cyber' than the 'Man'). Meanwhile Nardole is proving useful, though he is something of a Marmite character. I have warmed to him, but my other half described him as 'like K-9 only without the charm.'
All in all, it becomes apparent that the situation is without hope, but the Doctor has to try, because that is what he does, and Peter Capaldi gets to deliver another moving speech. The Master and Missy manage to cancel each other out in a glorious moment of self-destruction.
Ultimately, though, the ending with a deus ex machine, or more literally dea ex lacrimis, was a little disappointing, and rather too similar to the last series, with a companion who is sort-of dead surviving to fly off round the universe with a female companion.
The final moments bode well for Christmas, though. Roll on December!
After a very nice celebration lunch we were home in plenty of time for the Doctor Who finale, hoping that it wouldn't turn out to be a disappointment that spoiled the day. I've found that with two-parters the set-up is often better than the conclusion. So was that the case here?
There was a lot to enjoy, particularly the situation with Missy and the Master. Missy is in two minds about whose side she is on "fortunately one of them is unconscious."
But the scene soon shifts from the creepy hospital to floor 507, where settlers are protecting the children in a homestead straight out of The Waltons. Bill is having identity issues (though I wonder why she has more problems with the 'Cyber' than the 'Man'). Meanwhile Nardole is proving useful, though he is something of a Marmite character. I have warmed to him, but my other half described him as 'like K-9 only without the charm.'
All in all, it becomes apparent that the situation is without hope, but the Doctor has to try, because that is what he does, and Peter Capaldi gets to deliver another moving speech. The Master and Missy manage to cancel each other out in a glorious moment of self-destruction.
Ultimately, though, the ending with a deus ex machine, or more literally dea ex lacrimis, was a little disappointing, and rather too similar to the last series, with a companion who is sort-of dead surviving to fly off round the universe with a female companion.
The final moments bode well for Christmas, though. Roll on December!
Monday, 26 June 2017
World Enough and Time
Monday 26 June 2017
We missed the broadcast of Saturday night's episode owing to a prior engagement watching David Troughton (The Curse of Peladon and Midnight) playing Titus Andronicus at the RSC. After an extremely gory evening, we settled down on Sunday morning to watch World Enough and Time.
Having enjoyed the previous two episodes, I didn't have particularly high hopes, particularly as I find season finales tend to be a bit disappointing. I have seen online reviews suggesting that the episode was ruined because two of the biggest shocks had been made public in advance. Well, maybe, but the chances of keeping them secret would have been about the same as those of the Daleks taking up charity work. On the other hand, Bill's fate was a genuine shock. And despite the leaks, I failed to penetrate the Master's disguise. How could I have been so dense?
The idea of dropping Missy into a typical Doctor-type scenario to see how she got on was inspired. I can't wait to find out what happens next week. Unfortunately, next Saturday is a significant date, the sort of date that you might go out to celebrate.
Fortunately the husband has already thought of that. "I've booked a table for lunch" he told me.
Saturday, 17 June 2017
What Have the Romans done for Who
Saturday 17 June 2017
Bill is an expert on the Ninth Legion.
Of course she is. New Who companions have a thing about the Romans. Amy's obsession with Romans became part of a trap for the Eleventh Doctor, and the Tenth Doctor took Donna to see the Colosseum, or would have done if the TARDIS hadn't gone slightly off course and landed them in Pompeii on volcano day.
Bill is also an excellent student. She is prepared to argue the point with her tutor, and to undertaken her own first-hand research - even if she has make use of a handy time machine to do it. But her hypothesis about the fate of the missing legion turns out to be slightly off target. She didn't allow for the effects of a dimensional gateway and some light-eating locusts. Must try harder.
Rona Munro's long-awaited return to the series was an enjoyable and largely traditional story. The Doctor and his companion split up and gain the trust of opposing groups who eventually join together to defeat the larger threat. There's nothing wrong with that. To my mind, Doctor Who is at is best when dealing with relatively small scale stories such as this. Whilst there is a threat that could consume the whole planet, confining the action to a single isolated location makes it easier to suspend disbelief than an epic with updates from all over the world.
Meanwhile, a reformed Missy is back in the TARDIS. I have a bad feeling about next week....
Saturday, 3 June 2017
It's all thanks to the Monks
Saturday 3 June 2017
*Spoilers*
*Spoilers*
I didn't write much about last week's episode because I really didn't like it that much. I've mentioned before that I prefer self-contained smaller scale stories to big story arcs and the whole planet mobilising against a threat. I particularly don't like the idea of the Doctor being made President of Earth.
Anyway, tonight's episode picked up events six months later, and our hero has apparently turned into a sort of modern day Lord Haw-Haw, broadcasting about how the wonderful Monks have always been there, shaping humanity's progress. I wonder how they got on with the Fendahl, Fenric, Scaroth and all the other aliens who have been guiding humanity over the millennia?
Ha! Trick question! Because of course they didn't get on with them at all, as they weren't really there. It is all a lie. Martha still knows this, but struggles to keep her grip on reality. Of course the Doctor must be a prisoner, and being forced to help the Monks, mustn't he?
Until the end of the scene on the prison ship, the episode promises much. But having thrown everything at what turns out to be a gigantic fan wind-up, it rather runs out of steam after that. There are some obvious parallels between this episode and Last of the Time Lords. Both start from a point where the earth had been taken over by aliens at the end of the previous episode, and the action starts some months later with the companion, the being in the aliens' power. The ultimate resolution, using the alien's telepathic gizmo against them, is also the same. And they both feature the Master (or Mistress.) The one significant difference here is that Missy is not responsible, and having (almost) turned over a new leaf, she provides the Doctor with the clue to the Monks' weakness.
All in all, despite great performances from Pearl Mackie, Peter Capaldi and Michelle Gomez, I found this rather dull.
Saturday, 6 May 2017
Knock, Knock
Saturday 6 May
Tonight's episode was apparently named in honour of a joke so old that we were telling it in the playground when I was at primary school. Are 'knock, knock' jokes still a thing in the 21st century, or as they as dated as Angel Delight and blue PE knickers?
Bill is moving into a house share and the Doctor is helping. Is this the first time that the TARDIS has been used as a removal van? But whilst she is happy to have assistance with transporting her things, she really doesn't want the Doctor interfering in the normal part of her life and embarrassing her in front of her new housemates. You don't get rid of the Doctor that easily, though, and it turns out the suspiciously cheap house is not at all normal.
It looks nice enough and has large rooms and lots of potential. It's surprising that it hasn't been snapped up by a property developer - all it needs is central heating and rewiring. Or does it? Something nasty is lurking in the woodwork, and it isn't just deathwatch beetle.
This was a classic creepy (or creaky) house story. It reminded me of the X-Files episode War of the Coprophages, but with added Scooby-Do, even down to the sinister caretaker, sorry, landlord, played brilliantly by David Suchet. Scooby-Who, perhaps?
Sunday, 30 April 2017
Thin Ice
30 April 2017
*Contains mild spoilers*
*Contains mild spoilers*
In last night's episode the Doctor and Bill find themselves at the last great Frost Fair on the river Thames. But something nasty is lurking below the ice....
In a way this episode could also have been called The Beast Below if that title had not already been taken. There are some other similarities with that story in that both involve a giant creature being abused by humans. But unlike the starwhale, we learn little of the nature of the monster in the Thames.
The real monster in Thin Ice is, it turns out, not a giant creature, or even an alien, but a human (though not humane) being, Lord Sutcliffe. Sutcliffe was very much a pantomime villain, but whilst the allusions to slavery and imperialism struck me as a little heavy-handed, we had the opportunity of seeing the Twelfth Doctor give another of his rousing speeches, whilst demonstrating an impressive right hook.
Overall, I enjoyed this episode far more that last week's. The frost fair, complete with elephant, was well-realised, and this time the Doctor and Bill had people with whom they could interact throughout the episode. If there was something of a fairytale ending, what is wrong with that?
Saturday, 29 April 2017
Personal Tutoring
Friday 28 April
As a university administrator, I have been worrying that the current series may give a slightly unrealistic impression of what can be expected from a personal tutor. One of my colleagues has been doing quite a lot of work recently on personal tutoring arrangements, so I asked for his views on the Doctor's arrangement with Bill.
It turns out that there are quite a few problems:
As a university administrator, I have been worrying that the current series may give a slightly unrealistic impression of what can be expected from a personal tutor. One of my colleagues has been doing quite a lot of work recently on personal tutoring arrangements, so I asked for his views on the Doctor's arrangement with Bill.
It turns out that there are quite a few problems:
- Giving tuition to a non-fee paying unenrolled student (unless the Doctor went back in time to sort out Bill's UCAS and Student Loan applications)
- Favouritism
- Teaching outside core hours (tutorials at 6.00 p.m.)
- Daily tutorials, which are not scalable in today's mass higher education system and are not sustainable from a resource point of view
- 'Field work' undertaken without a risk assessment or ethics approval
- MASSIVE health and safety concerns
His conclusion? "Mind-blowing educational experience notwithstanding, this clearly calls for a solid bureaucratic crackdown, BUT if ownership of the bigger-on-the-inside technology reverts to the university* then all is forgiven."
* This would depend on the university's intellectual property policy.
Thanks to Dr Arne Hofmann for kindly giving me permission to post this.
Sunday, 23 April 2017
Smile!
22 April 2017
Smile is another one of those episodes where perfectly normal behaviour suddenly becomes perilous, as in don't blink!, don't breathe!, stay out of the shadows! but to my mind is rather less successful than such stories as Blink and Silence in the Library. I may be rather biased, as unlike Bill, whose face is always 'doing expressions' when she doesn't want it to, my face tends to look naturally glum, whatever I am thinking. Often what I am thinking is homicidal thoughts about the passing strangers who interrupt my perfectly happy thoughts by calling out "cheer up love, it might never happen!" so a world in which you have to smile or face being composted was hardly likely to appeal much.
It started well, with the Doctor sneaking off in the TARDIS with Bill whilst Nardole was making the tea, and the futuristic city looked fantastic. However, there was something not quite right about the pacing. A large chunk of the episode involved Bill and the Doctor exploring on their own, without all that much happening, and then the ending, once the colonists awoke, seemed oddly rushed.
It seemed rather out of character to me for the Doctor's first instinct to be to blow the city up, rather than to fix the robotic malfunction. Even if he believed that the colonists were arriving in a separate ship, what did he think would happen to them when the colony ship arrived to find a bomb site rather than a functioning city?
My biggest problem though was with the whole 'smile' thing. The mood badges were placed on the back. The implications is that they sensed mood (like those mood rings that used to be popular), so how would a faked forced grin make any difference?
Overall, some nice ideas, but could have been so much better.
Saturday, 15 April 2017
The Pilot
Saturday 15 April 2017
It turns out th
at the Doctor has been hiding out in a university, rather like Professor Chronotis in Shada. As a university administrator, I'm glad he didn't choose mine. I bet he never gets paperwork in on time and is really annoying in meetings (if he turns up at all.) I wonder if he is research active for REF purposes? What sort of feedback does he get in the NSS?
After a long break from our screens, the Doctor has returned in an episode that is in many ways reminiscent of Rose. It was very much about introducing the new companion, Bill. If first impressions are anything to go by, she will be good. Her initial reaction to the TARDIS ('like a posh kitchen') was hilarious. But it occurs to me that I need a new kitchen soon. I wonder whether the other half would be more convinced if we went for a TARDIS look?*
The episode is called The Pilot. It turns out that there is something lurking in the university that needs a pilot, and Bill inadvertently becomes involved. But the title has a double meaning. The episode is a sort of reboot, and the focus is on Bill's initiation into the TARDIS rather than the wider peril.
at the Doctor has been hiding out in a university, rather like Professor Chronotis in Shada. As a university administrator, I'm glad he didn't choose mine. I bet he never gets paperwork in on time and is really annoying in meetings (if he turns up at all.) I wonder if he is research active for REF purposes? What sort of feedback does he get in the NSS?
As a Doctor Who fan, I am disappointed that he didn't choose my university. After all we have a Cruciform, the inventor of the Panopticon and I could have loaned them a spare Dalek if they needed one...
*Edit: he has now seen this post and says he wouldn't. But I bet he would really.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
Featured post
Extenuating Circumstances
A while ago I pointed out that my university colleague and I had concerns about the personal tutoring arrangement between Bill and the Docto...
-
Since its return in 2005, Doctor Who has provided viewers with an ever-growing list of commands. Quite are few are prohibitions - mostl...
-
The UK Drama Channel (Freeview channel 20) is currently showing some classic Doctor Who stories, one for each of the pre-2005 Doctors on Su...
-
Sunday 28 December It’s been a couple of days now since I first saw Last Christmas, and I’m still not sure what I think. I really did not...